Nice list, some movies on the list I've never seen, but a lot of the ones on there that I have seen are definitely underrated.
The Taking of Deborah Logan is one of the scariest possession movies out there, and In the Mouth of Madness is just a fun one with nice monster effects and the Lovecraft vibe. Ghost Story and Mirrors are good too. All in all I think they made a good list.
I've not heard of most of those. Now I want to watch them.
I don't think Stir Of Echoes could be considered underrated. I think it has received a lot of attention and praise over the years. Same with Zombie. That is considered one of the best zombie flicks of all time. I don't get those two being on the list.
Rammbock is something I'd consider underrated. Got a lot of people to check that out and like it, and rightfully so. Great flick.
I wouldn't really say Sleepaway Camp is underrated either, I know plenty of people who love the whole series, but especially the first movie. You did get me to check out Rammbock and I did like it. It is underrated. There are a bunch of older movies that stand the test of time that I would consider underrated. Burnt Offerings, The Sentinel, Trilogy of Terror, a bunch of them. Maybe on another list.
I see the Sleepaway Camp series, while known and popular enough, still a series of cult classics and more fitting on this list than Stir of Echoes or Zombie. Especially the sequels 2 and 3. Man, those are stupid fun.
Of the movies that I've seen off of that list, I'd say most are pretty scary. A lot of people thought Terrifier was silly, and if anything, most probably think it's overrated, lol. But I actually liked it. I liked All Hallow's Eve too, I think just for the randomness of who he decided to kill. I don't know, but I liked them.
The Changeling is creepy and a really good ghost story that a lot of people have never seen or even know about. Hush definitely doesn't get enough credit, I thought it was awesome. I need to see some of these, meant to see Tusk when it was new, just never got to it. Really miss Michael Parks, liked him a lot.
I'd say that's a pretty solid list as well.
Checking out either Tusk or The Blackcoat's Daughter tonight. Both sound pretty good.